A tribunal has determined that the UK government must cease concealing its technical capability notice directed at Apple, rejecting the Home Office's claim that disclosure would harm national security. The Investigatory Powers Tribunal delivered this judgment on Thursday, finding that the government had violated its own confidentiality protocols.

Under the Investigatory Powers Act 2016, technical capability notices allow authorities to compel companies to alter their services to enable data access. The Home Office had previously maintained a position of neither confirming nor denying that such a notice had been issued to Apple.

Anyone with even a passing interest in this topic already knows that the respondent has served a technical capability notice on Apple

the three tribunal judges

Government's own secrecy rules breached

The tribunal found that the government had failed to adhere to its stated confidentiality policy. Both The Times and the Financial Times had published reports citing government sources confirming the order's existence, and the judges established that ministers, senior officials or special advisers had authorised these disclosures.

Though the Home Office claimed that leak investigations had identified no source, it provided the tribunal with no substantive details of these inquiries. The judges also noted that the government had permitted Apple to brief senior United States officials about the matter, which they characterised as another clear violation of its own policy. They further observed that information about the order was readily accessible through a simple search query entered into Google's chatbot.

The ruling does not expose the order's full contents to public view. The judges accepted that publishing all material would compromise national security. However, they determined that this does not necessitate complete secrecy of every aspect, with the tribunal to determine later which details may be disclosed.

What comes next

The parties anticipate a comprehensive hearing during the first half of 2027. The judges indicated that much of this proceeding can now occur publicly. Apple has presented five grounds for challenging the notice.

  • The tribunal can hear the first two grounds entirely in open court
  • One ground questions whether the power extends to interception occurring outside the UK
  • Another examines whether the power can be employed to regulate the security protections a company provides to its users

Apple responded positively to the tribunal's decision, viewing it as progress toward greater public transparency in the proceedings, according to Bloomberg. Caroline Wilson Palow, legal director of Privacy International, described the outcome as a "major victory" for transparency. Privacy International and Liberty, which had mounted a separate challenge alongside two individuals, also characterised the result as a win for transparency.

The Home Office characterised the ruling as procedural in nature. In a statement published by The Register, the government noted that Apple has collaborated with police and intelligence agencies for many years, and that the notice merely requires the company to maintain its capacity to assist these agencies.

Decisions affecting the safety of the British public must be made by democratically elected governments and independent judges, not in the boardrooms of technology companies

a government spokesperson

Apple submitted its second challenge in July, following the tribunal's rejection of its initial claim. In February 2025, the company discontinued Advanced Data Protection for UK users—a feature that extends end-to-end encryption to iCloud backups and additional services. Meta, TikTok and X similarly contested UK data demands this autumn, directed by Ofcom, and reportedly did not succeed in their challenges.

Source: The Next Web