Beginning 16 December, Etsy and its business partners would have been permitted to leverage seller content for developing and training artificial intelligence systems. The policy sparked an exodus of established merchants, some operating their storefronts for over a decade. In response, Etsy announced it would modify the controversial language in its updated terms of service. The New York Times' Reggie Ugwu broke the story of the seller departures and the company's subsequent reversal on Friday.

The revised terms scheduled for 16 December would grant Etsy and its "third party partners and vendors" the ability to leverage seller content to "develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies." According to reporting from the Times, the previous version contained no provisions regarding AI usage.

Merchants exit the platform

Multiple long-standing merchants announced their departure from the platform. Illustrator Aaron Millard shared on Instagram that he was shutting down the shop he had maintained for nearly ten years, noting that sellers lacked any mechanism to exclude themselves from the arrangement.

Kristen and Geoff Zephyrus similarly closed their storefront after selling home goods and stationery under the Cognitive Surplus name for 13 years. Kristen Zephyrus expressed her concerns to the Times, stating: "For Etsy to be helping to train algorithms with our human content is just unimaginably awful."

Company offers revised language

James Ossman, Etsy's vice president for customer operations, addressed the backlash through a post on the company's website this week. He stated that Etsy will not "use your content to train A.I. models designed to copy your original work or replace your creativity."

Ossman explained that third-party access to seller content would be limited to specific applications including fraud prevention and marketing purposes. In remarks to the Times, he committed to distributing the updated terms to sellers in the near future, emphasizing that creative works remain the property of their creators.

Skepticism persists among observers. Tyler Wilde, US editor-in-chief at PC Gamer, published commentary on the clause, characterizing it as sweeping authorization to apply AI training to user-generated content across any application. Wilde advocated for Etsy to implement an opt-in system rather than opt-out, keeping all sellers' work outside AI training initiatives by default.

History of seller friction

This represents another chapter in Etsy's contentious relationship with its merchant base. In 2022, over 20,000 sellers staged a coordinated strike protesting a fee restructuring that increased the base transaction fee from 5% to 6.5%. The Times also reported that Etsy strengthened its content moderation policies in October, restricting low-quality AI-generated material following user complaints.

The current dispute emerges as Etsy navigates broader organizational challenges, having eliminated 12% of its workforce in August. The controversy also reflects mounting resistance to AI across industries and society. This week, Donald Trump Jr. told Axios that investors had miscalculated the strength of public opposition to AI. Separately, Elton John called on Australia to establish protections for artists against AI at the Aria awards ceremony.

Source: The Next Web